HomeAboutMusicBlogMentorship Contact

How to get into a top grad school for composition

Ever feel like getting into a top grad school for composition is just about luck or connections? I wanted to prove that it's not, so I personally mentored a composer who was completely stuck, and 12 months later he was accepted into one of the world's top composition programs with a scholarship. Here are the 3 key shifts that got him into that program.

Saad HaddadBy Saad Haddad, composer

Here's the video this post comes from (11 minutes), or you can read it below.

  1. You're writing what you think other people want to hear
  2. You write the piece, then hope someone might play it
  3. You're waiting until grad school to seek mentorship

1. You're writing what you think other people want to hear

As soon as I started working with this composer, I had to identify the single biggest issue blocking him. If we didn't fix this first, it would have seriously reduced his chances of getting into a top grad school.

This is my former student London, and here's how he felt before we began working together: "I was super lost. I didn't know what I should be writing. I didn't know what people wanted."

Like a lot of composers, London didn't know what kind of music he actually wanted to write. So he defaulted to writing what he thought other people wanted to hear. But when you do that, you end up sounding like one of thousands of composers all writing the same kind of safe, generic music.

When I first heard his piece, I immediately noticed a few things. It wasn't that the music was bad at all. At first listen, it actually sounds really pleasing. It has a nice perpetual motion in the piano. There's a nice motivic gesture in the strings that goes against it, with the triplets against the eighth notes. And there are these nice little glockenspiel hits and pizzicato hits that enunciate different chord changes in the piano.

But when it comes to a grad school application, or getting performances of your music as a concert composer, the problem with a piece like this is it doesn't really show off the personal aesthetic of a particular composer. It does quite the opposite. It shows how a composer can blend in to a specific genre, which works really well with film music and not so much with concert music.

At first listen
  • Perpetual motion in the piano
  • A motivic gesture in the strings
  • Glockenspiel and pizzicato hits

Sounds really pleasing

On a grad school application
  • Doesn't show off a personal aesthetic
  • Can blend in to a specific genre
  • Works really well with film music

Not really a great fit

If you write in a tonal aesthetic, you have to follow its rules

Besides the aesthetic considerations, there were also problems with the technique within the more classical and romantic style of this piece.

He has lots of chords that are just your basic triadic chords, where you have a first degree, third degree and fifth degree of a chord. And many times he's doubling a pitch in the triad that shouldn't be doubled at all in this context, which is the third of the chord.

If I have a chord that's C, E, G, the E shouldn't really be doubled and tripled this often within this aesthetic. We should really have it happening once, maybe 2 times maximum if it's in a percussive instrument.

In bar 15, we have a C major chord. The piano is playing E's, the glockenspiel is playing E's, the viola is playing an E, and the second violin and the first violin are playing an E in octaves. So there's this huge abundance of the pitch E, when really we should be hearing the pitch C the most often in this chord configuration. And this happens all throughout the score.

Bar 15: a C major chord
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Violin I Violin II Viola Cello Glock. Piano
There's this huge abundance of the pitch E, when really we should be hearing the pitch C the most often in this chord configuration.

If I were looking at this piece as someone on an admissions panel, and I didn't really care about the aesthetic at all (which, by the way, they do), that would be one thing glaring out at me. This particular candidate doesn't have a grasp of the technique of the aesthetic he's writing in.

You can have your own preconception of what aesthetic you want to write in. But if you choose to write in a more tonal aesthetic like this, you do have to follow the 4-part harmony rules that are a part of that aesthetic. That's the danger of writing in this kind of style, because there are just so many different rules you have to follow.

If you get more and more into the modern era of concert composition, you'll notice that a lot of rules get broken much more often. So it's a careful consideration we have to make when we're writing in this more tonal aesthetic.

What I've seen valued the most in grad school applications

When we're applying to a grad school program and trying to make our names known in the concert music community, what I've seen valued the most is a really clear aesthetic style, a really clear personal voice, a brand if you want to call it that. That's really what's going to attract a specific kind of audience to you rather than anybody else.

London's piece, for the most part, is quite well-crafted. But how would an admissions panel be able to identify if this composer has the potential to have a clear artistic voice that would attract performers, that would attract audiences, and that would propel him in a career in concert music?

How to fix it

For us to get closer to London's aesthetic identity, we had to come up with a road map that he could follow as he was writing his grad school portfolio. Once we clarified that using the music that genuinely excited him, everything started to shift. He knew what he stood for musically and what kind of pieces would help him grow in that direction.

The first piece he wrote under this new plan was for clarinet and accordion, instruments that felt completely natural to him since he's also a professional accordionist. The music instantly sounded more personal, colorful, playful, and full of that bal musette energy that reflected his real musical background.

It has elements that are more personal to one specific composer, and not something that you can imagine lots of different composers doing to blend into a preexisting genre.

Before the road map
  • What he thought other people wanted to hear
  • Basic triadic chords
  • Lots of different composers could be doing it

A preexisting genre

The first piece under the new plan
  • Clarinet and accordion
  • Personal, colorful, playful
  • Full of that bal musette energy

His real musical background

That piece became the foundation for the next 12 months. We used his road map to shape 4 new works, each one reinforcing his aesthetic voice and building toward a cohesive grad school portfolio. By the end of that process, London had completely changed how he approached composition.

4new works, each one building toward a cohesive grad school portfolio

When you define your aesthetic road map, everything else becomes easier, because you stop writing for people and start writing for yourself, just like London did.

2. You write the piece, then hope someone might play it

Now that London had figured out what kind of music he wanted to write, the next step was a mindset shift, one that would keep him from falling into another trap that holds a lot of composers back.

Even when you know what your goals are, it's still easy to write pieces that don't actually move you toward those goals. And if your work isn't moving you forward, that goal isn't a goal anymore, it's just a dream.

So how do we avoid wasting our limited composing time? It starts with mindset.

Before our mentorship, London approached composing pretty passively. He'd come up with an abstract idea, write the piece, and then hope that someone might play it one day. And even when he did find performers, he often felt disconnected. The performances didn't reflect what he imagined, and he didn't know how to collaborate effectively to get better results.

How London approached composing before
  1. Abstract ideahe'd come up with one
  2. Write the piececomposing in isolation
  3. Hopethat someone might play it one day
  4. Disconnectedthe performances didn't reflect what he imagined

How to fix it

That's when I told him something that completely changed his approach. Stop writing for performers, start writing with them.

In other words, stop composing in isolation and then searching for people to bring the music to life. Start with the performer first, their sound, their instrument, their personality, and build the piece around that.

Once London flipped that switch, everything changed. He already knew plenty of musicians. All he had to do was reach out and say something as simple as this.

"Hey, if I write something for you, would you be interested in playing it?"That single question

That single question led to 9 musicians in his immediate circle getting excited to collaborate and commit to guaranteed performances.

9musicians in his immediate circle, excited to collaborate and commit to guaranteed performances

But it didn't stop there. These weren't just one-off performers, they became partners in the process. They told him exactly what they loved playing, what felt awkward, and what techniques showed off their strengths.

London used all that feedback to write music that fit each player like a glove, and because of that, every performance sounded confident, expressive and alive.

What they told him
  • What they loved playing
  • What felt awkward
  • What techniques showed off their strengths
Every performance sounded
  • Confident
  • Expressive
  • Alive

All 4 pieces he wrote in this way ended up in his grad school portfolio, the same portfolio that got him into his dream program, the Peabody Institute.

3. You're waiting until grad school to seek mentorship

Everything so far depended on one final idea. If this hadn't been in place, everything else would have fallen apart, because this was the part that allowed London to position himself as a top candidate at one of these elite conservatories.

The underlying issue holding most composers back usually comes down to 2 things: a lack of guidance and a lack of accountability.

But here's the catch-22. One of the biggest reasons people go to grad school in the first place is for that guidance and for that accountability. The lessons, the mentorship, the structure, it's all just part of going to grad school.

What's holding most composers backA lack of guidance and accountability
Why people go to grad school in the first placeThat guidance and that accountability

So how are you supposed to get that kind of guidance and structure before you're even accepted into a program like that?

How to fix it

Here's what London did. He knew he needed that support system, but he wasn't going to wait for a school to hand it to him. As he told me, "When I came to you, I knew that I needed to become a better composer in order to get into grad school."

London understood something that most people overlook. If you wait until grad school to seek mentorship, you're already behind. He knew that having someone guide him, push him and hold him accountable would accelerate everything.

In his words: "Mozart had teachers, Beethoven had teachers, Philip Glass had teachers, you know."

But London didn't stop there. He took that principle and expanded it, reaching out to other composers he knew, both locally and online, to form a community of peers who supported and challenged each other to keep writing.

"I think thinking that you can do it on your own is fine, DIY, whatever, but having someone and not only someone, but a whole community is going to help you grow faster, quicker, and better."London

You can have clarity of voice, you can have the right mindset, but without a network of people holding you accountable and cheering you on, progress often slows to a crawl. That's exactly what helped London not only get into his dream school, but continue growing beyond it.

Most people think success like his requires luck, connections or perfect circumstances. But at every step, London proved the exact opposite.

He took ownership of his goals, figured out what was missing, and built the systems to get there.

So if you're serious about composing and you have a big goal for your music career, you already have what you need. You just need the right mindset and the support to make it all happen.

What to do next

If you want the exact road map London used to develop his compositional voice and get into his dream grad school, you can download my free 5-step guide that shows you exactly how to do that.

Keep reading

Was going to Juilliard for composition worth it?There's no one best music school for compositionYou're going to be nervous at your composition auditionAll posts on music school