HomeAboutMusicBlogMentorship Contact

What gets a score performed again and again

Ever wondered why some pieces get performed over and over while others just sit in a drawer? I've analyzed over 1,000 scores from my own subscribers, and there's a surprising pattern, beyond just the music itself, that can make all the difference. Here are the key factors most composers miss, and how you can give your piece the best shot at getting performed again and again.

Saad HaddadBy Saad Haddad, composer

Here's the video this post comes from (21 minutes), or you can read it below.

  1. Find a professionally engraved score first
  2. Sharps going up, flats going down
  3. Keep the same enharmonics within one bar
  4. Study scores by composers living today
  5. Say the poem out loud
  6. Look at what a published choir piece looks like

1. Find a professionally engraved score first

The first piece is for string quartet, one of the most common ensembles you can have in concert music. When I look at this piece, right off the bat, I see a glaring mistake in the way the piece is presented.

At first glance, it looks kind of okay. You have violin 1, violin 2, viola and violoncello, in the correct order. The clefs, the key signature and the time signature are all in the right place.

But if you look to the left-hand side, between the staves and the instrument names, you have what are called brackets. And this is not the standard way that brackets are created for a string quartet.

How do I find out?

This is a little hack I like to use every time I'm writing a piece. Whether it's for string quartet, for orchestra, for solo piano, or for kazoo and accordion duo, what I like to do, first and foremost, is go and find a professionally engraved score online.

Preferably one by one of the big publishing houses, because these are the folks shaping the way these scores are going to look. It doesn't really matter which one.

For the sake of argument, go with Boosey and Hawkes. On boosey.com, go to where it says composers at the top, then online scores on the left, then browse all scores. Since this is a piece for string quartet, I just search for string quartet and see what comes up.

I picked James MacMillan's String Quartet No. 3. A really great feature is that you can see the score right there on the website without having to purchase anything.

What I like to do every time I'm writing a piece
  1. 1
    Find a professionally engraved score onlinePreferably one by one of the big publishing houses.
  2. 2
    Search for string quartetOr orchestra, or solo piano, whatever it is.
  3. 3
    See the score right there on the websiteWithout having to purchase anything.
  4. ?
    Do you like the way the style looks?The title pages, the cover pages, the inside pages.
  5. 4
    Copy the styles that you likeOr at least get some inspiration.

What I always recommend composers do is literally just copy the styles that you like. There's no reason for you not to do it if you like the way the style looks.

One simple thick bracket

If I take a look at the way James MacMillan has his piece, it has all the instrument names in the correct order, but the bracketing is much different. You just have one simple thick bracket. And as you go through the rest of the score, all the brackets are the same, all through the piece.

One simple thick bracket Violin 1 Violin 2 Viola Violoncello

Compare it to the piece that we were looking at, which made the bracketing way, way too complicated. If this composer had just kept the vertical line, that would have been enough.

If you're wondering what things I'm looking for exactly in these scores, I have a free engraving checklist that you can download and check out for yourself.

2. Sharps going up, flats going down

The second thing I noticed as I was going through that string quartet is the way the accidentals are spelled. This is going to be a real make or break when a musician takes a look at this piece, because they'll kind of know if you're serious or not as a composer.

Take measures 28 and 29. You have D sharp, which is fine. Then you have D sharp again. This is from the key signature, so that makes sense. G natural, so far so good. Then you have a bar line that separates these 2 measures, and a G on the downbeat.

According to normal accidental rules, we'd know that this is a G sharp. However, there's a G natural that comes right before it.

Make it crystal clear after the bar line

We want a G sharp written right there, without even a cautionary. I would just put a G sharp on that downbeat. The rules dictate that after a bar line, the accidentals reset. But for the sake of clarity for the musician, you want it crystal clear that you're coming from G natural to a G sharp.

We see that issue happening in the cello as well. There's the exact same line a couple of octaves down, and we want to make sure that this also reads G sharp and have it be consistent vertically.

If I were to respell all this

In that same bar, there are other accidental issues as well. Normally, as you're going up in pitch, especially if you're playing some kind of melody, you want to make sure the accidentals are teetering towards being sharp rather than being flat.

For example, this is a G sharp on the downbeat, a B flat on the second beat, and then a B natural on the third beat. Normal conventions of accidentals want you to have that B flat as an A sharp, because we want to read sharps going up, and we want to read flats going down.

If I were to respell all this, I would put D sharp, G natural, G sharp, A sharp and B natural. That would be the de facto way that I would do it, just for the ease of clarity of reading.

Measures 28 and 29: the key issue
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 28
This G that's on the downbeat, with a G natural right before it. Then a B flat on the second beat and a B natural on the third beat.
If I were to respell all this
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 28
D sharp, G natural, G sharp, A sharp and B natural. Sharps going up, flats going down.

So again, sharps going up, flats going down, and you want to maintain that as much as you can. Of course, there will be scenarios where that won't be possible. But generally speaking, that's what you want to do, especially in accidental-filled music.

3. Keep the same enharmonics within one bar

The next example is for solo piano, and it's quite pleasant on the eyes. It looks really professional: the way the tempo markings are written, the spacing in between the staves, the spacing of the notes themselves, the number of staves per page. The composer clearly knows what piano pieces typically look like.

When you look at it on a macro scale, it doesn't look like there are many issues. But when you look at it on a micro scale, things start to get complicated quickly when they probably didn't have to be this complicated.

It's clearly a piece with a lot of accidentals, which is perfectly fine. But in the first bar, I see a lot of accidentals that are being repeated with the other enharmonic. We have an A sharp in the right hand of the piano. Then later on in that same bar, we have a B flat. We have to flip our brain from A sharp to B flat all of a sudden.

And not just A sharp to B flat, but also A sharp to A flat, which happens later in the bar. The left hand has a G sharp, which is enharmonically the same pitch as the A flat in the right hand. There are all these mental gymnastics happening already in this first bar.

How to fix it

One quick fix I would have done with this composer is I would have possibly just spelled everything in flats, and that would have made things a lot simpler. So C, E, G sharp, C would be C, E, A flat, C. And F sharp, A sharp, D, F sharp would be G flat, B flat, D, G flat. Everything else would just be spelled as it is, and everything would look really, really clean.

This first bar: mental gymnastics
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Misterioso    = 66 sub.
A sharp, then B flat in the same bar. G sharp and A flat in the same bar.
One quick fix: spelled everything in flats
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Misterioso    = 66 sub.
Exactly the same music, but a lot clearer.

It's exactly the same music, but a lot clearer, because now we just have the flats to focus on as a piano player.

The lesson with this is, if it's a possibility, especially within one bar, to keep the same enharmonics, you want to do that. It'll make the music a lot less intense for the player to interpret. If the player has to interpret A sharp, then B flat in the same bar, there's a lot of mental overload that could happen quite unnecessarily.

Do a second pass when you're done with the piece

This is the key thing. This composer might say, "Hey, no, this is actually the harmony that I was thinking in my head." That's all fine and good. You should definitely write that harmony out when you're sketching the music and when you're putting it into a notation software.

THIS COMPOSER MIGHT SAY

Hey, no, this is actually the harmony that I was thinking in my head.

That's all fine and good. But what you'll need to do is a second pass when you're done with the piece.

A second pass to make sure that all the enharmonics are written as simply as possible.

These days, musicians don't have all the time in the world to practice your piece. They're practicing tons and tons of music, especially those at the conservatory level, pre-professional level, professional level. Their goal is to get to know your music as quickly and intimately as possible so they can do right by your music.

Anything that we can do to make that path easiest for them, we want to do.

The same kind of pattern continues. In the last bar, we have a B double flat that could have just been written as an A in this context. We also have an A natural in this bar, and those are the same pitch. So we might as well just label them both as an A natural. It'll make a lot more sense for the pianist.

We want to be really careful about how we spell these accidentals for the ease of playing by the player, because after all, that's the goal: to get these pieces played.

4. Study scores by composers living today

An example of a contemporary piece for piano that really works well, a piece that's just ready to be performed and has been performed, is one by my friend Tyson Davis. You can easily find it on the internet.

It's really well engraved in terms of the way the piano is written in the grand staff. It's a textbook example of how music with lots of accidentals should be written.

In the bar at the end of the first system, there's an F sharp instead of a G flat, and then an F natural. Normally, I'd probably want a G flat there going down to an F. But because there are 2 G naturals, Tyson put an F sharp, which makes the second pitch an F natural.

Horizontally, this isn't as good as G flat to F. But G against G flat would just be very strange vertically.

The short story is that there are a lot of these little games that we have to play, and it's so much easier to play them if you have really great example scores like Tyson's to look at and to learn from.

Little tricks you can learn from studying other people's scores
The tricks with accidentalsThe beamingsThe grace notesThe octave signThe location of the dynamic markings

Not only the tricks with accidentals, but also the way he's doing all these beamings, the way he's doing the grace notes, the way he's using the octave sign, the location of the dynamic markings. There are so many little tricks you can learn just from studying other people's scores, especially scores of composers that are living today, just like Tyson.

Do your research

Do your research. Look for scores that really connect with you, especially those by contemporary composers, because you'll learn a ton from them when crafting your own scores and making them as presentable for performance.

5. Say the poem out loud

The last piece is for SATB choir. A big thing that I see is the way that some of the text is set. Especially when you're writing vocal music, you want to be as naturally aligned with what the text is doing.

"I wrote the past" comes several times at the start, and there's a little bit of a play on where the stress is, which is pretty cool. But when we get to the second system, we have "I wrote the past in characters," and that's tough for me to even say.

I'm not the best singer in the world, by far. But even saying it without any pitch is kind of awkward.

How to fix it

When you're writing for choir, or anything that has text, what I like to do is say the poem out loud into my phone or some kind of voice recorder. I say it kind of slowly and really enunciate.

Then I stop myself, wait for a few minutes, listen back to the recording, and see if I can objectively hear where my voice stressed certain syllables.

What I like to do with anything that has text
  1. 1
    Say the poem out loudInto my phone or some kind of voice recorder.
  2. 2
    Say it kind of slowlyAnd really enunciate.
  3. 3
    Wait for a few minutesThen listen back to the recording.
  4. ?
    Where did my voice stress certain syllables?See if I can objectively hear it.
  5. 4
    A more natural singing styleAnd rhythmic style for the pieces that I'm writing.

One of the composers I like to look at is Dale Trumbore, a composer who writes a lot of choral music and has her music up on her site. A lot of the text that she's setting is quite natural when you speak it. For example, the alto line, "Life is short, and we do not have much time," is almost like how I would say that line.

6. Look at what a published choir piece looks like

Besides how the text is set, the overall look of the score could look a little bit more like how a choir piece is stylized. So again, I want to look at what a published choir piece would look like, and I go to the first page of Dale Trumbore's music.

The lyrics look so scrunched up

The lyrics in general just look so scrunched up. All these times where it says "wrote the past," there's something very tight about all the lyrics next to each other, and it rubs me the wrong way, to be quite honest with you.

On Dale's first page, a lot of the music is quite smaller in terms of the font size, and that's typically what choruses do. The fonts aren't as large as an instrumental part.

You really do want a rehearsal pianist

You'll notice there's a rehearsal piano marking on her score. When you're writing a piece for choir, you really do want to have a rehearsal pianist. Even if this person isn't there, it gives you the option to have somebody playing this line to help the choir out.

Most of the time I see this kind of grand staff for a rehearsal pianist in a choir part. It's pretty natural to do, and it's something the submission is missing.

Dynamics at the top of the staff, lyrics at the bottom

On the first page of the submission, there are no dynamics anywhere, which we really need to change so that we know what the character of the piece is.

Dale starts right from the beginning of the piece with some kind of dynamic, which is something I see composers miss often. They don't write enough dynamics in their music. She has dynamics literally on every single page.

And see if you can spot where her dynamics are. They're right at the top, which is something different for choral music, if you didn't know this before. The dynamics are always at the top of the staff, while the lyrics are at the bottom of the staff.

Dynamics at the top of the staff Life is short, and we do not have much time Lyrics at the bottom of the staff

On the second page of the submission, when the dynamics do start, they're in the wrong place. This is something we can fix easily and really simply. At measures 22, 23 and 24, all we've got to do is put these dynamics above the staff.

A breath mark is a bold little comma

The very last thing is a figure that looks like an up bow for the violin. In this context, it doesn't really mean anything. What I assume this composer is trying to do is put a breath mark.

A breath mark would be notated with a bold little comma that goes right between the pitches. If these were the 2 notes and you wanted to breathe in between, you'd put the little bold comma right in between those 2 pitches.

No dynamics anywhere on the first pageStart right from the beginning with some kind of dynamic
Dynamics in the wrong placePut these dynamics above the staff
No grand staff for a rehearsal pianistSomebody playing this line to help the choir out
A little up bow where you wanted to breatheA bold little comma right in between those 2 pitches

What to do next

To see exactly how I'm looking at these scores step-by-step, download my free engraving checklist.

Keep reading

Orchestral score details that cost you the players' trustWhat the first page of your chamber music score says about youWhy performers pass on your solo pieces before playing a noteAll posts on scores and parts