HomeAboutMusicBlogMentorship Contact

Why performers pass on your solo pieces before playing a note

Ever wonder what a performer decides the first time they open your score? They decide it before they play a single note, and it determines how much blood, sweat, and tears they'll give your piece. Here are the exact details in 3 solo pieces, for piano, flute and cello, that make a performer commit to your music or quietly pass.

Saad HaddadBy Saad Haddad, composer

Here's the video this post comes from (21 minutes), or you can read it below.

  1. What I call the falcon view
  2. The first page of music should always be on the right-hand side
  3. The title and the tempo marking
  4. I need to see beat 3 and I need to see beat 1
  5. The dynamic I avoid like the plague
  6. Be consistent with what you're doing
  7. There's no need to make up your own style
  8. Respect for the person on the other side

What I call the falcon view

After working with hundreds of musicians myself, I can spot this pretty fast. So I reviewed 3 subscribers' solo works: a piece for solo piano, a piece for solo flute and a 2-minute piece for solo cello.

What I always like to do first is what I call the falcon view. I look at a broad perspective of what I'm looking at, a bird's eye view, like I'm up here flying around.

The piano piece looked like a very legitimate solo piano piece. So it passed the falcon test, and I wanted to look a bit deeper under the hood.

What I always like to do
  1. 1
    The falcon viewA broad perspective, a bird's eye view of the score.
  2. ?
    Does it pass the falcon test?Does it look like a very legitimate solo piece?
  3. 2
    Under the hoodZoom in and look a bit deeper.

When I see little signs that a composer knows what they're doing in terms of the presentation of their score, it just elevates the music already in my mind before I even listen to it. Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing, that's just reality.

If I'm looking at 100 scores a day, because that's part of my job as a composer and as a teacher, I'm going to find things in pieces that are really good versus pieces that are not so good, especially with the presentation, that are telltale signs for me that there are problems with the music.

It just elevates the music already in my mind before I even listen to it.

The benefit of the doubt

The flute piece looked great from the falcon view. Later, when I zoomed in, I saw something with the accidentals that was definitely unusual to me.

But this composer had the benefit of the doubt, because of how the score already looked from the falcon view. So I'm thinking, it's probably just me. I probably have to go back into the program notes and performance notes.

If you're wondering what I'm actually checking these scores against, it's my engraving checklist.

The first page of music should always be on the right-hand side

The general advice is to have the music start on the right side, unless there's some crazy page turn where you need the music to start on the left side.

The flute piece had a program note and some performance notes, and all of that looked really nice and professional. Then the piece itself started on the right-hand side, with the first page number hidden.

The even pages are always on the left, the odd pages are always on the right, and page 1 is always hidden. You'd be surprised how many scores I see from composers that don't do this.

Music starts on the right 2 3 Page 1: always hidden Even left, odd right

With the cello piece, I didn't know exactly how the composer was printing it out, so I looked at it in booklet form. It was only one page of music, so it's not a big deal. But in general, we want the first page of music to be on the right-hand side.

It's a very small detail, but you've got to imagine a performer. They have a big stack of music and they're flipping through it. They're going to be used to seeing the first page of music on that right-hand side more often than not.

So you want to be congruent with what the rest of their packet looks like. You might as well do it if you remember it.

A little bit of white space

From the falcon view, the cello piece looked pretty good. The vertical spacing, the horizontal spacing and the staff size all looked great.

I do think the margins were a little bit small. I've seen a lot of music that has margins like this, but I personally prefer a little bit more space so the performer can actually write in the margins if they need to.

In the piano piece, a pedal marking in the top system was very, very close to the ritardando in the system below it. You want to avoid having systems be too close together. A little bit of white space there will help a lot for clarity's sake.

The title and the tempo marking

The title should be larger than the subtitle

In the piano piece, I saw the title and then the subtitle, the movement number, and the roles looked a little bit reversed. Normally, you'd want the title to be a little bit larger and the subtitle to be a little bit smaller.

I'd also prefer that the title is in all caps. In most titles, not always, but usually, you see them in all caps. A movement number would have the first letter capitalized and the rest lowercase.

The title
  • A little bit larger
  • Usually in all caps
The movement number
  • A little bit smaller
  • First letter capitalized, the rest lowercase

It's a very broad rule. But this piece didn't look like it was outside of a more conservative aesthetic, so I'd keep it in that kind of modality.

The cello piece had a nice-looking title page. I'm not a big fan of the artsy title pages myself, but that's a very subjective thing. I like the simple black and white title pages, because they're easy to print and I don't have to spend money on color ink.

90 is not a real metronome marking

This is something people don't like me saying, but the metronome marking in the piano piece, 90, isn't really a real metronome marking on the metronome. I've basically memorized these by now. The one before it is 88 and the one after it is 92.

It's more of a bigger deal if you're on a jury panel. If you're just giving the piece to your pianist friend, it's not going to be the biggest deal in the world. But if you know that and you see this, it does trigger something in your mind.

That's just my little pet peeve, and I've heard other composers say this too.

How to fix it

If it's possible, give a metronome marking that already exists on the metronome, so it doesn't create that kind of brain disconnect.

And in the cello piece, the tempo text, slow and expressive, was in regular font. It's definitely more standard to have this kind of tempo text in bold, so I'd just change that.

I need to see beat 3 and I need to see beat 1

Another big thing I saw in the first system of the piano piece was a giant set of 16th notes. If I'm a pianist trying to play this, I'm getting immediate brain fog. I'm in 4/4 and I can't see all the beats.

In 4/4, I want to see beat 3 and beat 1. If I don't see beat 2, it's not the end of the world, and beat 4, that's also fine. But I definitely need to see beat 3 and I need to see beat 1.

When I tried to point out the notes in each beat, I couldn't really see very clearly where they were. That's literally the whole point of why we want to separate the beaming out.

A giant set of 16th notes
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
I'm in 4/4 and I can't see all the beats.
Every single beat
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
Each beat as a beaming group.

How to fix it

Separate the beaming. At the very least, do that for beats 1 and 3.

I'd even take it a step further, if I'm being honest. I want to see every single beat as its own beaming group. That's going to make it a lot clearer for the pianist to read.

The dynamic I avoid like the plague

The piano piece had mp written twice in one spot. That's a typo for sure. But I wouldn't even write mp at all.

Mezzo piano is one of those dynamics that I avoid like the plague. I'd rather see piano or mezzo forte.

In this case, the composer probably means piano, because we see a crescendo later to mezzo forte. At quarter equals 90, that crescendo happens over 2 and a half beats. Mezzo piano to mezzo forte is almost imperceptible over 2 and a half beats.

As written: mezzo piano to mezzo forte over 2 and a half beats
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
Almost imperceptible.
What I'd rather see: piano to mezzo forte
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
A lot more dynamic. There's more to interpret from the player's perspective.

If it started from piano, the crescendo is going to be a lot more dynamic, pun intended. There'd be more to interpret from the player's perspective.

Not always, by the way. Mezzo piano does have its place in some moments. But in moments like this, where you're defining the dynamic level of an entire gesture or an entire phrase, it's usually not the most helpful dynamic that I've found.

If you disagree, you disagree. That's just my experience.

Be consistent with what you're doing

Clef changes

This isn't a big deal, but you do want to be consistent about it. In the piano piece, a treble clef came right before a 16th note, which is technically the correct way to do these clef changes. But in the very next gesture, the bass clef came before an 8th rest, and the music started after the rest.

I've seen it done both ways. But the way I think is more professional, and more congruent with what most people do, is to put the clef right before the first note of the next music in that clef.

It's a lot clearer, and it avoids this weird gap where you have the bass clef and then the music happening a little bit later because of the rest. It's a small little change to elevate the professionalism of the score.

Bar numbers

The flute piece had no time signature at the start, and there was a strange discrepancy with the bar numbers.

If there's no time signature, what I'd do is make every system a new bar and put system bar numbers: 2, then 3, and so on. That way it's consistent.

Double bar lines

Later in the flute piece, there was a time signature and a new tempo. I missed it at first.

What I would've done, so it's super clear for the player, is put a double bar line right there, especially because there's a new tempo and a time signature when there was no time signature before. A double bar line would've grabbed our attention a bit more about the change that's happening, and that change is very important.

In the cello piece, the double bar lines were not standard. The composer was pretty consistent about putting double bar lines where the time signature changes, and not having them in the tempo spots.

Where the tempo changesDouble bar line
Where the time signature changesSingle bar line

How to fix it

With the tempo changes, you put the double bar line. Where the time signature changes, you just need a single bar line. It's just a matter of changing that.

There's no need to make up your own style

In the cello piece, indications like pizzicato and arco sul tasto were in italics, with a box. That's not standard notation when it comes to these kinds of indications for strings.

Normally, we want these in regular font, with the period, no box, right above the pitch. There's no need to make up your own kind of style in this situation.

Part of the reason is that tempo indications like accel. are usually the ones you write in italics. So this clashes visually with what you have.

The mistake: in italics, with a box
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 pizz. pizz. harmonic arco, sul tasto
Tempo indications like accel. are usually the ones you write in italics, so this clashes visually.
The fix: regular font, no box
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 pizz. pizz. arco, sul tasto
Regular font, with the period, no box, right above the pitch. And you don't even need to write the word harmonic.

Over pressure goes at the top

The cello piece also had what I think was an over pressure marking, in other words, pushing the bow down. Typically, we like to see this indication at the top. Otherwise it kind of looks like a crescendo marking.

We don't want to put the over pressure below, because it mixes with the hairpins, the crescendos and the diminuendos. It becomes mentally strange to see that in the same spot where the dynamics usually go.

The mistake: over pressure below
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 accel. molto rit.
It mixes with the hairpins, the crescendos and the diminuendos.
The fix: over pressure at the top
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 accel. molto rit.
Typically, we like to see this indication at the top.

If you look at scores by the late Saariaho, she's like the queen of this kind of notation. Take a look at any of her stuff and you'll see what she does.

What you don't need to write

The flute piece had the instrument abbreviation in the score. I'd just get rid of that, because we know it's for flute. There's only one person playing, so they don't need to be reminded that it's flute.

The nice thing is, if you take it out, you'll have a little bit more space in case there are bars later in the piece that are kind of squished together. You'd be surprised. Sometimes this amount of space will make a difference, especially in a more complex-looking piece.

The same piece showed a natural sign every single time a pitch was shown. If it's already natural, you don't need to write natural. I'd want to see an E natural if there was an E flat in the same bar and you're canceling it out, but that didn't seem to be the case here.

I looked back at the performance notes and I didn't see anything about those accidentals. So if it was me, I'd probably get rid of those naturals.

In the cello piece, you don't even need to write the word harmonic, because we see the harmonic over the pitch. We know it's a harmonic.

And in the piano piece, the 3s over the 16th triplets were colliding with the slur. We don't want any collisions. You can put the 3 on the bottom. Or you can put the 3 on the first one and hide them in the rest, because you don't really need to write out all the 3s if there's just a bunch of 16th triplets in a row.

You can. It's not illegal or anything. The cops aren't going to be called on you for writing 3s everywhere. But you definitely don't want to have collisions.

You don't need to write
The abbreviation, when there's only one person playingNatural, if it's already naturalThe word harmonicAll the 3s in a row of 16th triplets

Respect for the person on the other side

Some of the things I've said here are a little bit nitpicky. But we can always improve. The name of the game is to always improve and to always grow.

The cello piece was already 90% there. It was super clear what was going on, and any cellist who picked it up would know exactly what to do. These things will just take it even further, to that professional level.

The flute piece looked really great, and it made me excited to actually hear the piece too. That's the added benefit of having a really good presentation. It makes whoever is looking at the score excited to really practice the piece.

If a performer sees that you really cared about how this thing was presented, they're going to feel more invested in giving a great performance of your music.

So it's not just about being nitpicky. That's part of it.

It's also about having respect for the person on the other side that's putting their blood, sweat, and tears in performing your music.

It's not easy to get up there on stage and play this stuff.

Saad Haddad working through a passage with a violinist
Working through a passage at the Columbus EarShot readings

Everything here was in solo pieces. That's one player reading off of one part. The moment you write for an orchestra, every one of these details multiplies across 80 players and a conductor who decides in about 30 seconds or less whether your piece is programmable or not.

1 player, 1 part 80 players and a conductor

What to do next

Download my free engraving checklist and run your own piece through it before you send it out to anyone else.

Keep reading

Orchestral score details that cost you the players' trustWhat the first page of your chamber music score says about youWhy orchestras don't perform your pieceAll posts on scores and parts