HomeAboutMusicBlogMentorship Contact

What the first page of your chamber music score says about you

When I open up a new score, the first page usually tells me the composer's level before I even reach the second system. Here are the exact details, from 3 of my subscribers' chamber music scores, that separate a score that looks professional from one that quietly works against you.

Saad HaddadBy Saad Haddad, composer

Here's the video this post comes from (20 minutes), or you can read it below.

  1. It shows if you've done your homework
  2. Don't hide your name
  3. Make it page number 1, then hide the number
  4. Put the tempo on the same plane
  5. Too much information on the first pitch
  6. The fermata that's missing in the piano
  7. Don't micromanage the piano dynamics
  8. Is the piece in 3/4 or 6/8?
  9. Spell the accidentals horizontally

1. It shows if you've done your homework

The 3 scores were a brass quartet, a piano trio, and an ensemble piece with clarinet, harp, violin and cello. I look at the whole first page in terms of the falcon view: what does the score look like if I'm just glancing at it from high up, without looking into detail?

The brass quartet passed. From a falcon view perspective, I could see that this composer had done their homework. They know how to present a score in a professional manner.

What passes the falcon viewGood note spacingGood staff spacingGood amount of white spaceGood tempo markingInstrumentation looks goodThe abbreviations look good

Oftentimes, I already know from looking at the first page the level of the composer, and how much detail and dedication they spent in actually presenting their scores.

How many bars per system

On the piano trio, I liked the number of bars per system. It was 5 for the most part, and 4 where there was a bit more music horizontally. Another system had 2, and there I would have liked to see at least 3 bars, 4 maybe.

Bars per system
For the most part5 bars
A bit more music horizontally4 bars
Quite a small number2 bars

If you're wondering what I'm actually checking these scores against, it's all on my engraving checklist, and it's free.

2. Don't hide your name

On the cover of the ensemble piece, the composer's name was in a little itty bitty font. Usually when people are thinking about music, in the classical idiom especially, they're thinking about the artist. So I'd put your name front and center.

Put it up at the top, put the title in the center, and you'll be good to go. Be proud of your work. That's the end of my sermon there.

The titleItty bitty fontYour nameThe titleLoud and proud

On the piano trio, the fonts weren't consistent throughout the cover page. One font screamed at me in terms of being very different than the rest. Double-check your font style, because you want that first impression to be crystal clear and without distraction.

We want them to pay attention to our music, so we don't want to attract attention to the cover page and the preface page. I just want those to lead nicely and simply into the actual music.

3. Make it page number 1, then hide the number

The brass quartet had the music start on the right-hand side with the page number hidden, and that's perfect. The piano trio started on the left. It's not the most important thing, but when I see a score opening like this, I wonder what other things are amiss.

The ensemble piece showed page number 3 on the first page of music. What I'd do is, in your software, make sure that this page is page number 1, and then hide that number. The next page is going to be page number 2, and we're going to be able to see it.

The first page of musicWhat I saw3Page 3What I would do1Hidden2Page 23Page 3

It's a very, very small detail, but it makes a big difference to someone that's looking at these details.

4. Put the tempo on the same plane

On the piano trio, the Andante was placed in the right spot. But the quarter equals 80 was not done in the traditional manner, and my eye went straight to that when I opened it up.

The quarter equals 80 should be placed right next to the Andante. You want it all on the same plane. That way it looks as if a publisher presented the music, and that's what we're always striving for when we're trying to engrave our music.

What I saw
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 = 80 Andante
My eye went straight to that.
What you want to do
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Andante = 80
Right next to the Andante, all on the same plane.

The ensemble piece was marked Adagio. It's not always necessary to write quarter equals 48 if you're using a very common tempo like that, because we know Adagio is a slow tempo. You can find it on the metronome.

Bar numbers and score order

The system bar numbers should be in italics. That's going to be the professional way to do it.

And be mindful of where the keyboard goes. In a piano trio, the typical score order is violin, cello and then piano at the bottom, and this composer did that correctly. If you're writing for orchestra, you want to put the keyboards above the strings.

5. Too much information on the first pitch

The first pitch of the piano trio said niente, molto crescendo, attacca imperceptible. I think this is honestly too much information. If you just wrote double P or even triple P, that would basically mean the same thing as niente.

And the molto crescendo doesn't make sense to me. At quarter equals 80, which is kind of a walking speed, this is a lot of time to do a molto crescendo. I could see one happening with a half note maybe, a big dynamic change in a short amount of time. From this point all the way to this point, it's going to be a gradual crescendo.

Niente, molto crescendo
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 niente, molto cresc. attacca imperceptible
I'm a bit confused on what you mean here.

It could be that you wanted piano all the way through, and then a molto crescendo right at the end. That would make sense, but then I would just indicate that with a hairpin.

The main point is that because of the way you notated the music, now I, as an interpreter, am not 100% sure what you mean. Guys like Brahms or Beethoven can almost get away with markings that aren't consistent, because so many people have interpreted them. Because we're writing new music, we don't have that luxury.

6. The fermata that's missing in the piano

In the second system, the violin and the cello have a fermata. However, the piano doesn't have a fermata written. That's a big interpretive marking that's missing.

I'm not sure, as the interpreter, did you mean to have the fermata on the first note, so that the 16th note is a bit longer? Or did you, most likely, mean having it on the dotted quarter note? We need to see that so we're aware of how the piano fits into this texture.

What I saw
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Violin Cello Piano
The piano doesn't have a fermata written. And the hairpins go nowhere.
On the first note?
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
So that the 16th note is a bit longer.
On the dotted quarter note?
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
Most likely.

The very same bar has hairpins that go nowhere, and that's my pet peeve. You could easily put some kind of dynamic there, so that we know where the music is ending up.

7. Don't micromanage the piano dynamics

I wanted to look at the second page too, because the piano has a bit more notes there. The piano line is written really well in terms of how the voices interact, with the stem up and the stem down. It is a bit strange, though, to see dynamics on both staves.

Typically with piano music, you're just going to have dynamics right in the middle, and that will describe the dynamic in both staves. Because of the way pianists are trained, they know how to voice the music they're playing. You don't need to be micromanaging the dynamics unless there's a really specific reason to do that.

Dynamics on both staves
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
It is a bit strange.
Right in the middle
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
I would put this mezzo forte right here in the beginning of the line.

In the bars after that, the left hand is slurred but the right hand isn't. As a pianist, I'm not sure how I would interpret the right hand. My thinking is you probably wanted a legato texture, so we want to show that in the piano writing.

8. Is the piece in 3/4 or 6/8?

On the ensemble piece, I saw some incongruencies between the time signature and how the music is notated. 6/8, more often than not, is going to be divided into 2 dotted quarter notes, 3 + 3. The clarinet had bars subdivided like they're in 3/4.

The same number of eighth notes6/83/4

The harp looked like a 6/8 kind of structure. Because it is an ensemble piece, it could be difficult to line things up if one part is being read in 3/4 and one is in 6/8. Really good musicians are not going to have a problem with this, but there might be a little bit of confusion in the very beginning.

How to fix it

If it was me and I wanted to keep everything in 6/8, I would change that half note to a dotted quarter note, tie it over to an eighth note, and then have the quarter note D.

Subdivided like it's in 3/4
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Clarinet
A half note, then a quarter note.
Told in 6/8
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Clarinet
It's exactly the same music, but just told in 6/8.

9. Spell the accidentals horizontally

The last thing that I check is the accidentals. I don't look so much vertically, because the other players are not really looking at the other parts when they're playing. They're more interested in what their part looks like horizontally.

That's especially true when each player is playing single pitches. For piano or a keyboard instrument, the harmony is going to be really important for them to know, since they're playing a bunch of notes at once.

On the brass quartet, trombone 2 goes F, B flat, E flat on the way up, and that has a nice spelling. If this composer did F, A sharp, D sharp, it wouldn't look as great. You would have this augmented third instead of a perfect fourth.

What this composer wrote
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Trombone 2 sub.
I like that the composer kept using flats.
If the composer used sharps
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 Trombone 2 sub.
An augmented third instead of a perfect fourth.

A few players can work out what you've got

Everything here was chamber music, where a few players can sit in a rehearsal and work out what you've got. A conductor is never going to give you that chance. There's more on that in why orchestras don't perform your piece.

Saad Haddad with the members of the Lydian Quartet
With the Lydian Quartet

What to do next

Download my free engraving checklist and run it through your own piece before anyone else sees it.

Keep reading

Orchestral score details that cost you the players' trustWhy performers pass on your solo pieces before playing a noteWhy orchestras don't perform your pieceAll posts on scores and parts