Orchestral score details that cost you the players' trust
Ever wonder what 70 professional players think when they open up a brand new score? Every detail on your page either builds their trust or costs you some of it, before even the first downbeat. I reviewed 3 subscribers' orchestral scores, and I'll show you the exact details that make an orchestra take your music seriously.
By Saad Haddad, composerHere's the video this post comes from (24 minutes), or you can read it below.
- These big, big key signatures
- There's no ending dynamic
- Every percussion instrument has a different staff
- The half note in the percussion
- 4 lines for the tremolando
- The bassoon is too high for the bass clef
- Who's playing on a shared staff
- A giant orchestra and a very specific duration
- Players perform from their parts
1. These big, big key signatures
The first score was a piece for orchestra, choir and solo voice. It had everything in the right score order, so very, very nice job there.
One thing that I'm looking at, which personally is another pet peeve of mine, is these big, big key signatures. 5 flats, 4 flats. 3 flats is not as big of a deal, but most of the instruments had 4 or 5 flats.
Maybe it doesn't bother everybody, but it does bother me. And I know that it bothers a lot of orchestral players, especially when they're playing new music that they've never seen before and it's not in the repertoire.
Never have I attempted to write an orchestra piece with a key signature this large. Other composers have, Ravel and those types of composers, fine. But you've got to remember, they're in the standard repertoire. They've been around for over 100 years, and musicians have been practicing these licks over and over and over again.
When you're a new composer, or a composer that hasn't had much of their music played, myself included by the way, we have to be cognizant of this fact. Yes, I've had a lot of my stuff played by orchestras, but nowhere near as much as Mozart or Beethoven or Brahms or Tchaikovsky or any of those guys.

One semitone up or one semitone down
This music could have easily been in a key signature that was either one semitone up or one semitone down. 5 flats means that this is in D flat major, if it's in major.
Either you go up a semitone to D, which is 2 sharps, or you go down a semitone to C, which has no sharps, no flats.
I don't see a real reason to be writing in a key like this when there are other keys available to you that are much, much easier to coordinate with 60, 70 players on stage. So that's my number one thing.
By the way, if you're wondering what I'm actually checking these scores against, it's all in my engraving checklist. You can download it and run your own piece through it before any orchestra ever sees it.
2. There's no ending dynamic
On that same score, I liked the way that it was laid out as far as the engraving goes. But if possible, what I'd like to see in the strings is maybe a piano marking in the middle of the hairpin.
If you don't want to keep writing piano and pianissimo over and over again, you can just write sim. and the players will know what to do.
Be consistent with where you place the dynamics
On the third score, I'd double check what the dynamic is in the clarinets. That's a major one that I look for.
In the second bassoon part, the pianissimo was in no man's land. We want to make sure that we're consistent with where we place the dynamics. That's a very simple one.
And in the cello line, the piano marking was repeated. It's a very small detail, but I'd just get rid of that, because it's very clear that all 3 of these pitches are piano.
3. Every percussion instrument has a different staff
The second score looked good from what I call the falcon view. If you're in the falcon view and can already see issues, that's going to make us pause when we swoop in.
If you present a score in a very professional way, the falcon view doesn't take very long.
One of the differences between the second score and the third was the way that the percussion was set up. On the third score, all the different instruments had a different staff: glock, cymbal, snare drum, bass drum, tam-tam. I've never seen anybody do this this way. That's not typical in an orchestral format.
Name the percussion players
You name the percussion players like this: percussion 1, percussion 2, percussion 3. Then within the part itself, you start specifying what the instruments are. This is the most common way that I've seen percussion be presented in an orchestral format.
All the percussion 1 material is on one staff, all the percussion 2 material is on one staff, and all the percussion 3 material is on one staff.
That's not typical in an orchestral format.
The most common way that I've seen percussion be presented.
Within each of these stations, we have several different kinds of instruments that could be played. On the second score, percussion 1 had the snare drum, and this could change to another instrument throughout the score. Percussion 2 had the bass drum, which can change to another instrument, and so on.
4. The half note in the percussion
The one thing I'd change on that second score is with instruments like the snare drum, the bass drum, the crash cymbal, that are really attack-heavy instruments. In other words, they're not instruments that have a sustain.
It's not like the piano, where I can just play a note and hold it. All of these are instruments where you hit it once, and then it either rings out or you dampen it.
The half note here is not a typical duration that they would see when they're just normally hitting.
How to fix it
In the snare drum, I'd just put quarter, rest, quarter, rest, and so on. That is what they're used to seeing. Same thing with the bass drum and same thing with the crash cymbal.
I'd stray away from the half notes unless it was tremolando. In that case, yes, you can notate any duration that you want.
5. 4 lines for the tremolando
On the third score, the timpani line had 4 dashes to indicate the tremolando. We want to avoid indicating the tremolando with 4 lines. That's not necessary.
How to fix it
All the timpanist needs, and really any of the other instruments too that use tremolando, like the snare drum or the bass drum or the tam-tam, is 3 lines.
This is going to be an unmeasured tremolando that's going to be as fast as possible. We don't need more than 3 lines to indicate that. So I'd change that to a quarter note with 3 lines.
A tie or not a tie
The snare drum part on the second score had a tremolando, which is basically just what's happening very quickly between the 2 sticks, and it used a tie. I've seen people use the tie. I've seen people not use the tie.
Me personally, I don't use the tie when I'm writing tremolandi across bar lines, but I've seen repertoire that uses it. So just be consistent. If you use a tie, just make sure you do that the entire piece.
6. The bassoon is too high for the bass clef
On the third score, the first bassoon was in this super high register. When you have notes in the bassoon that are this high up for this duration of time, what we want to do is not use the bass clef.
Change it to tenor clef
I know this is scary. But the beauty of the software is that it'll do it for you. We want to change it to tenor clef.
It looks like an alto clef with the viola, but remember, the alto clef is around the third line. The tenor clef is around the fourth line. In other words, that line right there is middle C.
You pop it into your software, and all these notes will start to move down into the staff. It'll look more readable for the bassoon player.
I'd actually use tenor clef from the beginning of the score, so that we don't have to deal with clef changes. The second bassoon part was in bass clef because we've got these Gs, so keep the second bassoon in bass clef.
Put the bass clef at the very beginning
The horns on the second score had a similar thing: treble clef and then bass clef. Because the music starts with bass clef, I'd just put bass clef at the very beginning.
That was a score in C, so you can do that. When you transpose this in the actual horn parts, this is going to be in treble clef, at least for that part. It's a very small detail.
7. Who's playing on a shared staff
The second score had 2 players on a staff in the flutes, oboes, clarinets and bassoons, and they were divided correctly. I really love how the composer paid attention and put an "a 2" (a due) in the bassoon. That indicates that both of them are playing these pitches.
The third score had horns 3 and 4 on one staff. Where they were both playing different pitches, it was notated correctly. Then, when just one of them was playing, it said "Hn 3."
The number 3 with a period
To me that's obvious, that you just want horn 3 to play. However, there's a more precise way that we do this. Write the number 3 with a period instead of horn 3.
That'll make it obvious to us that it's the third French horn player playing. Then once you get to the 2 pitches again, it'll become obvious that both 3 and 4 are playing. You don't have to notate anything.
Now, if both players were playing this line, we wouldn't write this. We'd write "a 2." So that's the distinction there.
8. A giant orchestra and a very specific duration
The instrumentation page on the third score had 18 first violins, 8 double basses, and so on. This is a Berlin Phil, LA Phil, New York Phil size orchestra. Just to let you know, it's quite rare to have an orchestra this size.
Normally, it's going to be 12, 10, 8, 6, 4. That's going to be your standard, regional-ish orchestra. As we get to the Berlin Phil, the LA Phil, typically it would be something like 16, 14, 12, 10, and then 8 double basses.
Just write strings
Normally, unless I have a very specific reason, I don't suggest how many players should be in the orchestra. I've done it before, but in very specific cases. Generally speaking, all you'd need to write here is just strings.
Round the duration
This is a little nitpicky, but I see people writing very specific durations a lot. I don't know why. This one had 6:09, and sometimes I see 5:27.
When I see 6:09, I'm like, oh, is there a click track? Why is it so specific?
Just say it's 6 minutes. It's never going to be exactly 6 minutes or exactly 6 minutes and 9 seconds. So round it down or up to the nearest minute. That makes the duration a bit cleaner to read and to understand.
9. Players perform from their parts
Even if your score passes everything we went through, that's only half of what an orchestra sees. Players never perform from your score. They perform from their parts, and badly prepared parts can sink a piece in the first rehearsal, even when the score is spotless.

The harp pedal markings
The second score had a nice, correct pedal marking in the harp. Personally, I don't put pedal markings in the score. In the part, I might, but in the score it's often not necessary. It's often clutter.
I wouldn't say go in and delete them. But the conductor is not going to be too enamored with that. That's going to be the harpist's responsibility.
All in all, it's just a few little tweaks. There was nothing major that was an issue on that page of the third score. But there's still another level that you can go to make it even more presentable and professional.
What to do next
Before any orchestra ever sees your piece, run it through my free engraving checklist. It's what I'm actually checking these scores against.
