HomeAboutMusicBlogMentorship Contact

Why your music isn't getting performed and how to fix your notation

Ever wonder why your music isn't getting performed, and why live musicians pass over your compositions? After examining hundreds of scores and parts sent in by my subscribers, I'm going to show you exactly how to fix your notation step by step, using 3 orchestral scores. It'll make your music that much more professional for live musicians to read and want to play.

Saad HaddadBy Saad Haddad, composer

Here's the video this post comes from (16 minutes), or you can read it below.

  1. Your score order and layout are wrong
  2. Your first page looks cramped
  3. Your metronome marking isn't a real metronome marking
  4. Your key signature makes the music more complex than it needs to be
  5. Your rhythms aren't the easiest version on the page
  6. We don't know who's playing what
  7. You forget the starting or the ending dynamic
  8. You write the word tremolo

1. Your score order and layout are wrong

The very first thing I want to see in an orchestral score is the score order.

The first score I looked at was a piece for woodwinds and strings, with no brass. From the top, it had piccolo, flutes, oboes, bassoons, clarinets.

The other thing I noticed right off the bat was an inconsistency in the bracketing. This is not the biggest thing in the world, but if you're going to write an orchestral score, you want to make sure that the legibility is 100% there.

And when I zoomed out a bit more, the score was in landscape. Landscape is not really a format that we use with orchestral scores.

That was all on the first page. I wasn't even looking at the other pages. Your first page is what creates the impression, especially the first page of music.

How to fix it

Yes, flutes are at the top, and then we want oboes. But after the oboes, we need to have clarinets. The correct score order would be piccolo, flutes, oboes, clarinets, including the bass clarinet by the way, and then the bassoons.

Submission number 1
  • Piccolo
  • Flutes
  • Oboes
  • Bassoons
  • Clarinets
The proper score order
  • Piccolo
  • Flutes
  • Oboes
  • Including the bass clarinetClarinets
  • Bassoons

Another piece, this one for full orchestra, had it right. It went piccolo, flutes, oboes, English horn, clarinets, bassoons, then horns, trumpets, trombones, tuba, then percussion, harp and strings. That score order makes a lot of sense.

For the page, an orchestral score is usually going to be the other way around from landscape. It's going to be in a tabloid size, which is basically a large vertical size paper. In the United States that's 11 inches by 17 inches, and if you're in Europe, I think it's A3.

In an orchestral score, it's always going to be vertical.

Landscape Tabloid 11 by 17 or A3 Not a format we use Always vertical

If you're wondering what exactly I'm looking for when I take a look at a score, I have a free engraving checklist that you can download and use for yourself.

2. Your first page looks cramped

A lot of this is first impression. It's really important that we make a good first impression on our musicians and our conductor. And if you're submitting to a call for scores, first impression is a big, big, big deal.

Saad Haddad discussing a score with a conductor
Talking through the score at the Columbus EarShot readings

On another piece for full orchestra, the first thing I thought right off the bat was, wow, all the staves are really, really tightly compressed. It made the page look really cramped.

This was the first page, and this is the page that everybody's going to see. It's really what we should be spending most of our time on if the goal is to get the piece played.

How to fix it

The first thing I'd do is decide for myself, how am I going to make this look less cramped? One of the ways is to combine staffs.

If you look at flute 1 and flute 2, you can easily combine these 2 staffs into one staff and just call it flute 1, 2. Then guess what? Your second staff is completely eliminated.

2 separate staffs
  • Flute 1
  • Flute 2
  • Oboe 1
  • Oboe 2

Really, really cramped

Combined into one staff
  • Flute 1, 2
  • Oboe 1, 2

Your second staff is completely eliminated

Same thing with the oboes: oboe 1, 2 on the same staff. The English horn I'd keep on its staff. With the clarinets and the bassoons, again, you can have all this music on one staff, and we can just keep going all the way through the rest of the brass.

This will save you so much space on the page, and it's so much easier for the conductor especially to see what's going on. On this page there were just a lot of goose eggs, a lot of whole notes. If we saw these whole notes on the same staff, it would be easier to see in a smaller amount of music what's going on exactly.

This particular piece wasn't overly complex, especially the first page, so that's not going to be the big factor. But I promise you, it does make a difference on a first impression for that first page to look as professional as possible.

3. Your metronome marking isn't a real metronome marking

At the very top of the first score, it said quarter equals 73. Quarter equals 73 is not really a real metronome marking.

When we deal with live performers in a concert music scenario, generally speaking, we want to stick close to what the actual metronome says. If you take a look at a metronome, it has a bunch of numbers all around it, and the numbers go basically in notches. If we start from around 72, the next notch above is 76.

The notches on a standard metronome 72 76 73 75 Not really a real metronome marking

We want to stay true to that, because the difference between 72 and 76 is not really that big.

Why this is in my head

When I did my interview at Juilliard, I believe it was the second time, for my master's degree, I had a metronome marking that looked just like this. The professor there, the late Christopher Rouse, took a look at my score, and the very first thing he pointed out was the metronome marking.

I thought that was interesting, because it pointed out something that was kind of novice of me to do. So nowadays when I look at scores, that's usually the first thing I look at, because of that encounter with Professor Rouse.

How to fix it

If I see 73, we might as well just use 72, because that's the exact metronome marking that we see on a standard metronome. Just change it to quarter equals 72 and you'll be good to go.

You'll start to see a pattern here. Another piece for full orchestra had quarter equals 75 at the very top. That should probably be 72, or more likely 76.

Quarter equals 73Just use 72
Quarter equals 7572, or more likely 76

And if all you have at the top is a tempo marking like Andante, I like to put the actual metronome marking there as well. Mahler and Brahms and Strauss and all those people can kind of get away without having one, because there's a tradition of tempos taken by conductors and ensembles.

But for new music, even if it's done in a tonal, traditional, conservative context, we really want to have that marking there. If you're using a very common tempo like Adagio, it's not always necessary, because we know that's a slow tempo.

4. Your key signature makes the music more complex than it needs to be

When you're writing an orchestral work, especially these days, rehearsal time is very, very short. For the piece that I wrote for the Los Angeles Philharmonic, it was crazy. I only had 66 minutes to get my 10-minute, kind of huge, gargantuan piece rolling.

66minutes of rehearsal time for my 10-minute piece for the Los Angeles Philharmonic

It was really not much time at all. So we want to make it as easy as possible for the musicians to play, even if the music is complex.

In the first score, the music wasn't very complex. But one thing making it more complex than it needed to be was the key signature. It had 5 sharps, the key of G sharp minor, I believe.

There's no real reason to have it in G sharp minor. You can easily have it in G minor or even A minor. All you have to do is move everybody up a half step or down a half step, and you'll get the same result.

Think about the open strings

When you think about strings, their best, most resonant form is when they're playing open strings. On the violin, that's going to be your G natural, your D natural, your A natural, your E natural.

If you're playing in a key that has 5 sharps, look what happens to G. Now you have to play G sharp. D is now D sharp, A is now A sharp, and the E is still a regular E, but you see what I mean.

Open strings on the violin
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
Your G natural, your D natural, your A natural, your E natural. Their best, most resonant form.
A key that has 5 sharps
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
Now you have to play G sharp, D sharp and A sharp. The E is still a regular E. We can't use the open strings.

Now we can't use the open strings, and we can't make the music that much more resonant. With strings, 9 times out of 10, we'd prefer to have that open sound, especially in the orchestra.

There are some cases, of course, where you don't want that. But in my view it's better to explore those open strings in your orchestral work.

How to fix it

These days I'd highly recommend not doing a transposed score, especially for orchestral music. In wind ensemble music, it's pretty common to use transposed scores.

But with new orchestral music, even if it's in a traditional tonal style, it's better to just have it without any key signature at all and put the accidentals in the music. You'll thank yourself later when you do this.

We don't really need a key signature in a new piece of music. But one composer did a great job in choosing the key signature, because it was quite an easy one, just one flat for the most part. That we could live with.

5. Your rhythms aren't the easiest version on the page

When I was double-checking the legibility on the second score, one bar had a glaring issue.

We're in the time signature of 4/4, and this composer had music on beats 3 and 4, with 2 quarter rests in the same bar.

There was another thing in this bar, a sextuplet. What I saw was 6 notes over the span of 2 beats, which is just more computation in the mind of the performer to handle.

How to fix it

In 4/4, if you have music on beats 3 and 4, you generally want to make sure that these 2 rests are combined into a half rest. We don't need to have 2 quarter rests there. It's much clearer and much more professional looking if we have a half rest.

And this sextuplet really is just 2 triplets. If they see 2 triplets, one triplet on one beat, another triplet on another beat, that's way easier to comprehend, and it'll get you the same exact result.

More computation
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
2 quarter rests, then 6 notes over the span of 2 beats.
Easier to read
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
A half rest, then one triplet on one beat, another triplet on another beat. The same exact result.

My whole mindset when I'm engraving music, especially with the intention of live performance, is that I want whatever I'm writing to be the easiest version I could have on that page for the musician to play.

At the end of the day, what we want to do is make sure that our music can be performed and rehearsed in the shortest amount of time possible.

That's really the goal at this stage of the process.

6. We don't know who's playing what

This is an often overlooked thing. When you have 2 instruments on one staff, we want to make sure that we know who's playing what.

In the second score, the horns were really well done. Typically speaking, we want to have horns 1 and 3 and horns 2 and 4 right after each other, and that's what this composer had.

The only extra thing I'd add is to make it crystal clear who's playing the line in horns 1 and 3. Otherwise we're not 100% clear.

Horns 1 and 3 on one staff
Is this just horn 1 playing?Is it a solo line for horn 1?Or is horn 1 and 3 playing?

How to fix it

What I'd write is the text a 2 (a due), that's a, space, 2, right above the staff. That way we know that horns 1 and 3 are both playing this line. I'd put it again, in parentheses, on the next phrase.

The same thing goes for horns 2 and 4.

You don't have to do that on the clarinets when they're separated, clarinet 1 and clarinet 2. But when they're both playing the same line on one staff, we need to know if both of them are playing it. It will make it that much easier in rehearsal.

7. You forget the starting or the ending dynamic

If you want your music to be completely legible, you've got to go down the staff lines and do this kind of analysis. In the tuba, I spotted a D with a crescendo.

It's really good that this composer put a tie over to the D on beat 3, because that shows beat 3 in the 4/4. But this crescendo into the rest leaves a lot to be desired.

What are we crescendoing to? Are we crescendoing to mezzo forte? Are we crescendoing to forte?

It's not clear. And a lot of times what I see in my students' music is that they do write a lot of dynamics, but they forget the starting and/or the ending dynamic.

How to fix it

We really need to have a dynamic marking there. In another spot, this same composer did it perfectly, with a starting dynamic and an ending dynamic. It's really important that we have both of these.

A crescendo into the restWhat are we crescendoing to?
A starting dynamic and an ending dynamicPerfect

8. You write the word tremolo

One last factor is the strings themselves. In the third score, the composer had the strings in the correct order. But the one major thing I saw that could be fixed was a tremolo figure, in other words, the effect of playing with the bow really quickly on the strings.

If we have the pitch C and it says the word tremolo, it's not immediately graspable to the performer, or even the conductor, what's going on.

How to fix it

With strings, what we want to see with tremolo is the notation that looks like 3 lines on top of the pitch. Instead of writing the word tremolo, we really want to see that visual representation of the pitch with the 3 lines.

The word tremolo
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46 tremolo
If it says the word tremolo, it's not immediately graspable to the performer, or even the conductor, what's going on.
3 lines on top of the pitch
Engraved by Verovio 6.4.1-fbe8f46
Putting 3 lines on top of the C, and we'd have to do it again on top of this C.

Every time it says tremolo, this composer should be putting these 3 lines on top of the pitch.

The next question becomes, do you need the ties? I've seen some composers put the ties and some composers not put the ties. I myself have sometimes not put the ties.

I don't think that part of it is a big difference in the grand scheme of things. The tremolo lines are the really, really big thing we need to be doing in terms of making this as legible as possible for the conductor and the musicians.

What to do next

If you want to get your music to a state where it can be performed and commissioned on a more regular basis, start with my free engraving checklist, which shows you exactly how I'm looking at these scores step by step.

Keep reading

Orchestral score details that cost you the players' trustWhat the first page of your chamber music score says about youWhy performers pass on your solo pieces before playing a noteAll posts on scores and parts