HomeAboutMusicBlogMentorship Contact

How to get commissioned as a composer

In 2024, I started an experiment. I took on a composer who was completely stuck, with no clear voice, no performances and no commissions, and after just 12 months his music is being performed internationally. Here's the process we followed, so you have a path to getting commissioned that's based on real life.

Saad HaddadBy Saad Haddad, composer

Here's the video this post comes from (11 minutes), or you can read it below.

  1. Define your aesthetic blueprint
  2. Fix the performer relationship mindset
  3. Write music that actually reflects your voice
  4. Watch the results compound

1. Define your aesthetic blueprint

I typically help composers who've already had some experience writing for live musicians. But for this experiment, I decided to take on a composer who was completely stuck.

The point was to prove that building a fulfilling path in this field is still completely viable right now, and that all you need is a simple series of steps to follow that will get you on that path.

12months from no clear voice, no performances and no commissions to music performed internationally

The composer is Jude, who's based in New Jersey. He'd been out of music school for about 2 and a half years when we started working together. As I was learning more about his situation, I quickly spotted what our first obstacle was going to be.

Here's how Jude puts it: "I lacked a clear identity as a composer." He thinks it's important for composers to be able to have "a crisp answer to the question of how would you describe your music?" And "before our mentorship began, I didn't know how to answer that."

This one issue ends most composing careers before they even start: a complete lack of artistic identity. Jude was jumping from style to style, piece to piece, with no connecting thread.

Take a piece he wrote in 2021. It's not bad music by any stretch of the imagination, but it sounds generic. It could have been written by hundreds or even thousands of other composers.

"I had a lot of pieces where I was careening wildly from one thing to another," Jude says.

Based on my own experience, I knew it was extremely important for Jude to focus on developing one clear artistic voice and nothing else. He calls it a brand, but since I'm a bit of an academic, I call it an aesthetic blueprint.

What this means is that if you try to write neoclassical one week, then spectral music the next, then baroque after that, you're just going to end up scattered, with no one really understanding what you do as a composer.

What's going to be your signature aesthetic?

The way I like to think about developing your aesthetic blueprint is like how a chef discovers their signature dish. A particular chef doesn't become known for cooking everything on the menu. They become known for that one thing nobody else can make quite like they do.

Think about Gordon Ramsay from Hell's Kitchen. He's known for a bunch of crazy stuff that he does in the kitchen, but in terms of his food, there's probably one dish that stands out above all the rest, and that's got to be the Beef Wellington. That's what people know him by.

Scattered
  • One weekNeoclassical
  • The nextSpectral music
  • After thatBaroque

No one really understanding what you do

Signature dish
  • The chefGordon Ramsay
  • The dishBeef Wellington

That one thing nobody else can make quite like they do

This is the signature dish. This is what people know you by. As composers, we have to do the same thing. What's going to be our signature aesthetic?

Get honest about your real influences

The first thing I had to do was get Jude honest about his real influences. This is where most composers get a little embarrassed. I even got a little embarrassed when I told my teachers what my influences were.

For Jude, one of his biggest influences was the American guitarist and songwriter Frank Zappa. I've seen most composers think they need to hide influences like that. But I remember telling him one day, "Great. Let's work with that and completely run with it."

Jude's real influenceFrank Zappa
What most composers thinkHide influences like that
What I told himLet's work with that

Jude describes Frank Zappa's harmonic system as "something called the chord bible," which is "basically a very big list of cluster-ish chords" that Zappa "used as the basis for his harmonic language."

2. Fix the performer relationship mindset

Getting Jude on the right aesthetic path actually created a completely new problem that we had to fix, or this experiment was going to fail. Even though he now had a clearer sense of his aesthetic, he was still approaching performers completely wrong.

Here's how he describes it: "I felt like I had to bend over backwards in so many ways to cater to performers and ensembles. And this included things like writing pieces without guarantees of performance, twisting pieces around into new arrangements with no consideration of the practicality of my time."

Approaching performers completely wrong
Writing pieces without guarantees of performanceTwisting pieces around into new arrangementsGrateful for any attention from performers

Does that sound familiar to you? Most composers think they need to be grateful for any attention from performers. The ironic thing is that this approach actually repels the performers who'd otherwise be interested in your work.

How to fix it

I had to get Jude to understand that successful collaborations require mutual respect, not desperation.

Successful collaborations require mutual respect, not desperation.

Jude says there was a point very early on where he had to make a decision: "I either need to make the mental commitment to trust him or I make the mental commitment not to." In his words, "that was the point where I went full on."

This is where Jude committed fully to his mindset shift.

3. Write music that actually reflects your voice

Even though we were making progress on his artistic identity and performer relationships, we still had one more critical step, which is to write music that actually reflects his voice.

We had to put theory into practice. Jude needed to write music that clearly demonstrated his new aesthetic approach.

The result was a piece for solo drum set and electronics. It doesn't sound like it could have been written by anyone else. This is clearly Jude's voice, incorporating his Zappa influences in a completely original way.

Before
  • 2021A piece he wrote before we started
  • How it soundsGeneric

Could have been written by hundreds or even thousands of other composers

After
  • The pieceSolo drum set and electronics
  • How it soundsClearly Jude's voice

Doesn't sound like it could have been written by anyone else

Going from generic to extremely personal music can definitely happen over a long period of time. But it can happen much more quickly if you follow a clear process for developing your voice.

A completely different kind of collaboration

There's something else about this piece. It came from a completely different kind of collaboration.

Jude was talking with a percussionist from the Netherlands, and he shared his portfolio of pieces to give her a sense of the kind of music he did. In his words, "she was a big fan of the portfolio, and she said to me, 'If you want to write a solo percussion and electronics piece, I can guarantee you a performance and a recording.'"

Jude shared She offered His portfolio A guaranteed performance and a recording

So instead of begging for performances, when Jude shared his portfolio, the performer immediately offered him a guaranteed performance and recording. This is what happens when you have a clear artistic identity coupled with that mindset shift.

4. Watch the results compound

This is where things got really interesting for Jude. Once he had clarity about his voice and was writing music that excited him, everything started to change.

But here's what I want you to notice about how these opportunities actually came about. He wrote a piece for flute. That person he met through a mutual friend.

Another piece he wrote for saxophone. That happened because that particular musician had worked with Jude as a conductor on a different project. And he finished a piece for E-flat clarinet for someone from his undergraduate days who owed him a favor.

A piece for fluteMet through a mutual friend
A piece for saxophoneHad worked with Jude as a conductor
A piece for E-flat clarinetFrom his undergraduate days

The fastest path to commissions and performances

Notice what's happening here? None of these performances came from cold emails or mass submissions. They all came from Jude's existing network: friends, classmates, people he'd worked with before.

Jude's existing network Jude Friends Classmates People he'd worked with before None from cold emails or mass submissions

This is the part most composers get completely wrong. They think they need to reach out to strangers and convince them to play their music. But the fastest path to commissions and performances is often just right in front of you.

When you do reach out to new people

That doesn't mean you can't or shouldn't expand beyond your immediate circle. You absolutely should. But when you do reach out to new people, the approach has to be completely different.

Here's an example of what this looks like in practice. Jude saw a Facebook post from a trombone and marimba duo looking for new repertoire. The performer posted that she was looking for modern, approachable music.

Instead of sending a desperate pitch, look at how he approached them. He's professional, direct, and immediately offers value. He mentions he also plays trombone, which creates an instant connection.

Desperate outreach
  • Sending a desperate pitch
  • Begging for a chance
  • Trying to convince them to do him a favor
Confident, professional communication
  • Professional, direct
  • Immediately offers value
  • Mentions he also plays trombone

Proposing a collaboration

He's not begging for a chance. He's proposing a collaboration. This is the difference between desperate outreach and confident, professional communication.

Jude isn't trying to convince them to do him a favor. He's offering to solve their problem. They need new repertoire. He writes music they'd want to play.

What happened in less than 12 months

Jude got accepted to New Music on the Point, a festival he'd applied to multiple times before and never got in, and he finished a residency there. His music started getting performed internationally, in places like Estonia, the Netherlands, and here in the United States.

In less than 12 months
Accepted to New Music on the PointPerformed in EstoniaPerformed in the NetherlandsPerformed in the United StatesWriting all the time

"I feel like I'm on the path to achieving everything that I want to achieve," Jude says. "I only began that path when I stopped holding myself to some idea of what my music was supposed to sound like, and started making the kind of music that I wanted to hear in the concert hall."

Here's what most people will miss about what happened with Jude. It wasn't about writing better music. It was about writing music that was clearly his.

You probably have music sitting on your computer right now that nobody's ever heard. The problem most likely isn't that you need to write more music. The problem is that you haven't given performers a clear reason to care about what you've already written.

But when you know exactly what kind of music excites you, everything changes. Instead of chasing opportunities, opportunities start coming to you.

Instead of chasing opportunities, opportunities start coming to you.

Jude has a much stronger sense of his aesthetic now, and of what he does well as a composer. As he puts it, "now I'm writing all the time because everybody wants to work with me."

That's exactly what happened with Jude, and it can happen for you, too. In all likelihood, you already have everything you need to develop a compelling artistic voice. You just need the right system to bring it out.

What to do next

If you want to start developing your own aesthetic blueprint right now, my free 5-step guide walks you through the exact process Jude used to discover his voice.

Keep reading

Why musicians don't reply when you email them your musicWhat 21 orchestras taught me about writing for orchestraWhat stops composers with day jobs from getting performedAll posts on getting performed and commissioned