How to study Bach chorales as a composer
It's really tempting to take a Bach chorale and just start writing Roman numerals ad nauseam below it. There's no way to kill your love of Bach chorales more than doing this exercise. Here's how I study Bach chorales as a composer instead, step by step, with a focus on the very first phrase of one of my favorites.
By Saad Haddad, composerHere's the video this post comes from (11 minutes), or you can read it below.
- Pick a favorite chorale and hear it first
- Figure out what's going on globally
- Ask what the melody is like
- Play the chorale first with your hands on the piano
- Notice what the rest of the voices do on a big leap
- Listen to what the bass line is doing
- Look at the text itself
- Ask what piques your interest on a visceral level
1. Pick a favorite chorale and hear it first
This book of chorales is my Bible when it comes to finding inspiration for functionally harmonic possibilities.
I was first introduced to this specific edition, by Boyd and Riemenschneider, while I was a student at the Juilliard School, and I've been referring to it ever since.
I want to go over one of my favorite chorales from this book, to show you a glimpse of how I, as a composer today, learn from arguably the greatest to emerge from Europe, Johann Sebastian Bach.
The chorale is Er ist das Heil und selig Licht, the one that closes Bach's cantata BWV 83.
This is not meant to be a thorough analysis of the chorale, as if we're completing a music theory assignment for school. Rather, I want to highlight what I personally find enthralling about this chorale, with a focus on the very first phrase.
In the video, I play the entire 1-minute chorale on the keyboard, though I encourage you to listen to the original choral version.
2. Figure out what's going on globally
Now that we've heard it, the first thing I want to do is actually figure out what's going on globally.
You'll notice that there are 6 phrases, each one with varying lengths. The phrases have a wide variety of beats: 8 beats, 6 beats, 10 beats, 5 beats, 7 beats. We have phrases that don't follow any kind of 4-measure structure at all.
I really love how circular this is. The first and last phrase have the same number of beats, and they nicely start and end with the same exact voicing, just with the third slightly changed.
3. Ask what the melody is like
The next thing I typically look at as a composer is, what is the melody like? That's usually the first thing I'm going to get caught by, especially if a piece of music has some kind of melody or tune that sings over the entire piece.
To be honest, the melody itself is not really that interesting. It's not something I would remember immediately after playing it.
The exception is between beat 4 and beat 5. There's this really interesting fifth that happens.
4. Play the chorale first with your hands on the piano
In terms of harmony, it's really just tempting to take the notation that you see on the page and just start writing Roman numerals ad nauseam below it. There's no way to kill your love of Bach chorales more than doing this exercise.
I actually suggest doing the opposite. Play the chorale first with your hands on the piano.
Kill your love of Bach chorales
What the heck is this?
So I play just the first phrase. What the heck is this? What are we doing?
What it probably should have been
To me, what makes this interesting is not exactly what he wrote on the page, but what it probably should have been.
What I do is stay as close to the melody that Bach did as possible. He does this thing where he goes D, A, A, G, D, C, B, A. I go as close as I can to that, and I play what I would have expected instead.
I would have expected an authentic cadence in D minor instead of going to A minor. In other words, that 2 chord in root position would have been a 2 6 chord, so a 2 chord in first inversion, going to 1 6 4 in D minor, to 5 7, to 1.
- 2 6a 2 chord in first inversion
- 1 6 4in D minor
- 5 7 to 1an authentic cadence in D minor
But here it doesn't do that at all.
What Bach does instead
This is what Bach does instead: D minor, 5 6, D minor again in root position, then root position E minor, which is 2 in the key of D minor. Then we have this D major, which would be 4 6 in the key of A.
We don't know if we're in A major or A minor though, because this chord actually exists more in A major than it does in A minor.
Then we go up in terms of passing tones, but really, if you play those all together, it's a dominant seventh chord in A minor. Then we actually get to A minor.
But then he doesn't stay there. He goes to another passing tone, D and F sharp, which creates this dominant 4 3 chord. And then finally he goes to E major, which has that seventh passing tone there, and then A minor.
- 1D minorThen 5 6, then D minor again, root position.
- 2Root position E minorWhich is 2 in the key of D minor.
- 3D majorWhich would be 4 6 in the key of A.
- ?A major or A minor?This chord actually exists more in A major than it does in A minor.
- 4Passing tonesIf you play those all together, it's a dominant seventh chord in A minor.
- 5A minorBut then he doesn't stay there.
- 6Another passing toneD and F sharp, which creates this dominant 4 3 chord.
- 7E major, and then A minorE major has that seventh passing tone there.
5. Notice what the rest of the voices do on a big leap
Besides the harmony, there are a couple other things that I really love about what Bach is doing. I alluded to the first one earlier, with that fifth in the melody.
When Bach approaches a big leap like this in his melody, going from G to D, which he doesn't do that often at all in this chorale, I noticed that in the rest of the voices, the voices move very, very slightly.
So when he goes from this E minor chord to this D major chord, the melody moves up a fifth while everything else moves by step.
6. Listen to what the bass line is doing
The second big takeaway I got out of this is what the bass line is doing. Here the bass line has its own melodic shape to it. It's not just the top melody itself, it's what the bass line is doing too.
It goes from D to C sharp, the leading tone, then D again, then E. Then this F sharp makes us almost think that we're in D major for a split second.
Then the G sharp actually makes us think, "Oh, maybe we're pushing to some kind of A sonority." Those are the last 2 notes before we get to A when it comes to an A major scale or an A melodic minor scale.
Then we have the A, then we get this cadential E, the 5 of A, and then we have A again.
2 strong melodic anchors
If I couple this with the melody, you can really tell that there are 2 strong melodic anchors happening at the same time. They help us figure out what we want to happen in the inner voices.
You'll notice that there is contrary motion from the very beginning. You have this D in unison, and then the bass line goes down and the melody goes up, at different intervals. The bottom is by second, the top is by fifth.
Then the top note stays the same and the bottom note goes up. The top note goes down, the bottom note goes up. Then the top note goes really up, and the bottom note just goes a little bit up.
Then we have a passing tone, and then the bass line goes up while the melody goes down.
Then we have a cadential figure, where the bass line goes to the 5 and the melody goes to the 2 of A minor. And then we land on unison tonic, just like we did at the very beginning of the phrase.
7. Look at the text itself
There's one last bonus takeaway, and that's the text itself.
When we get to a word like "hope," for example, isn't it strange that all of a sudden we get an E minor chord in root position? You would expect something to be a little bit brighter on the word "hope." But no, Bach doesn't do this.
Instead he realizes, "Oh, I gave them an E minor chord on the word hope. Maybe I should kind of remedy that right after," with this surprising D major chord, which doesn't exist in the key of D minor. Then he pushes this idea of hope ascending even further with this E7 chord, heading to the word "saving."
You would think on the word "saving" you would go to maybe something like A major. But no, we're in A minor, just like with the word "hope" we were in E minor, root position.
But again, just like the word "hope," we have this A minor chord going up to D7, so this kind of more happy sounding thing. And then on the syllable "ing," we have E major.
And then again, on a word like "light," you would think "light" would be in a major key. No, it's A minor again.
It's crazy to me. Bach is subverting our expectations. You would think on the words "hope," "saving," especially the first part of "saving," and "light," we would have major chords. That would make sense, right?
But no, he's saving these more major sonorities for kind of the offbeat parts.
8. Ask what piques your interest on a visceral level
It's not just enough to do a simple kind of Roman analysis of what's going on in a piece like this.My main takeaway
What are some of the other things that pique your interest on kind of a visceral level?
For me, it's some of these chord progressions specifically. It's the way the melody jumps while other voices are moving in more of a stepwise motion. And then finally, it's how the text interacts with what's going on in the music itself.
What to do next
If you wish, you can analyze the rest of the chorale like I've done with the first phrase. And if you want a framework for writing your own pieces, grab my free guide to composing any piece in 4 steps.
