HomeAboutMusicBlogMentorship Contact

Why writing more music won't get you commissioned

Have you ever wondered why some composers get constant commissions while others grind away unnoticed? I've learned firsthand, working as a composer with ensembles like the Los Angeles Philharmonic and the Minnesota Orchestra, that it's not about how much music you produce. Here are 3 lessons that will make commissions come easier and faster while writing less music.

Saad HaddadBy Saad Haddad, composer

Here's the video this post comes from (5 minutes), or you can read it below.

  1. Stop writing music as if your career depends on quantity
  2. The big trap: writing for ginormous ensembles
  3. How to build a reputation that leads to commissions

1. Stop writing music as if your career depends on quantity

This first lesson is going to help you write less music, but make every note you write lead directly to more commissions, more performances and more opportunities as a concert composer.

I want to show you how one of my students perfected this. Before he started studying with me, one of his former professors had asked him to write a solo piano piece for the first lesson. Sounds reasonable, right?

But the following week, the same professor wanted 2 piano pieces. And the week after that, you guessed it, 3 piano pieces.

What the same professor wanted The first lesson 1 solo piano piece The following week 2 piano pieces The week after that 3 piano pieces

By this point, my student started panicking. Anybody would. Who could possibly write that much music with real care or intention?

It's not hard to imagine what happened. First of all, he wasn't able to complete the 3 pieces, and second of all, the music he was trying to write really quickly wasn't any good.

A dangerous myth

But the real damage wasn't in the music itself. It was deeper. It was in his mindset. That experience left a scar.

He began believing a dangerous myth: that speed was the key to developing his voice, and that the more music he pumped out, the closer he'd get to being seen as a legit composer.

The result? His music became increasingly generic. He was finding it difficult for performers to have interest in what he was doing, and he didn't receive any commissions, either. Worst of all, I could tell he was beginning to lose some confidence in what he was doing.

How to fix it

So when we began together, I stepped in and told him to stop this endless cycle.

I remember saying to this composer, "Please, slow down. Write just one piece at a time. Make every note matter. Be thoughtful about what you're doing so you can keep track of the things that you're doing in your music. Don't move on until you feel comfortable with the music that you're writing right now. Be in the moment."

What I said to this composer
  1. 1
    Slow downWrite just one piece at a time.
  2. 2
    Make every note matterBe thoughtful about what you're doing so you can keep track of the things that you're doing in your music.
  3. ?
    Do you feel comfortable with the music that you're writing right now?Don't move on until you do.
  4. 3
    Be in the momentThat one carefully written piece, he got it played.

And then something incredible happened. That one carefully written piece, he got it played. And it's not because he was writing more and more and more, but because he was finally writing music that meant something to him.

Writing more and more and more
Trying to write really quicklyIncreasingly genericDidn't receive any commissions

That's how you get ignored

Just one piece at a time
Carefully writtenMake every note matterMeant something to him

He got it played

So the lesson here is that if you're currently writing music as if your career depends on quantity, please, please, please stop.

That's not how you get performed. That's how you get ignored.

2. The big trap: writing for ginormous ensembles

This lesson will dramatically increase your chances of having your music performed live. It's all about temptation, the big trap. And that is writing for ginormous ensembles.

Look, I get it. Notation software makes composing for orchestra, for example, incredibly easy. You open up a blank score on the computer, you drop in 30 staves, you load your favorite sample libraries, and suddenly you're conducting the Vienna Philharmonic.

A blank score 30 staves Your favorite sample libraries

But the harsh truth is that just because software makes it easy doesn't mean live musicians will actually play it.

Composers who regularly have orchestral works performed have spent years building their reputations. They've earned that trust by writing solo pieces, chamber music, and gradually expanding into larger ensembles. And you have to remember, they didn't start by writing a symphony. They started small, with an emphasis on getting those pieces played.

If you're just starting or restarting as a composer, writing for these massive forces too soon can trap you in this imaginary world disconnected from live performers and real opportunities. I see this cycle happening again and again around me.

Start with music that can be realistically performed

So if you want your music played, please start with music that can be realistically performed. Things like solos, things like duos, things like trios. Not because they're easier, but because they're more easily attainable.

Music that can be realistically performed Solos Duos Trios More easily attainable Ginormous ensembles

3. How to build a reputation that leads to commissions

Whether you write tonal, neoclassical, postmodern, baroque music, whatever it is, it really doesn't matter. And it doesn't matter because there are performers all over the world looking for exactly what you love to do, as long as it's clear and intentionally written.

That's actually really good news, because now may be the best time ever to be a concert composer. There are string quartets that specialize in spectral music, brass ensembles that want fanfares, percussionists who thrive on pushing the boundaries of what their instruments can do. What I'm saying is it's all out there.

String quartets that specialize inSpectral music
Brass ensembles that wantFanfares
Percussionists who thrive onPushing the boundaries

But the one thing they have in common is that they want music that means something, especially to the person that's writing it. Not music that's rushed.

So how do you actually build a reputation that leads to commissions? It's not by writing in any certain style or copying whatever aesthetic you think is in at the moment. It's by writing music that you genuinely care about and making it playable enough for the musicians that want to bring it to life.

What to do next

If this hits home for you and you're tired of writing music that just sits on your hard drive, start with my free commissioning guide, the simple system that gets musicians excited to commission and perform your music, again and again.

Keep reading

Why musicians don't reply when you email them your musicWhat 21 orchestras taught me about writing for orchestraWhat stops composers with day jobs from getting performedAll posts on getting performed and commissioned