What to check before you sign a commission contract
Most composers I know just take a look at a commissioning agreement, sign it right away and send it back. They don't teach you in music school what you're supposed to do when you receive one, so here's what you should look at and what to keep an eye out for, from how long the piece is to who owns the copyright.
By Saad Haddad, composerHere's the video this post comes from (17 minutes), or you can read it below.
- What the piece is for and how long it is
- When your piece is going to be performed
- Scores, parts and copying
- How they're going to pay for your piece
- Travel and accommodation
- Who actually owns the copyright
- Exclusivity rights
- Termination and cancellation
- If they don't give you an agreement
Some composers I know wait weeks and weeks before they sign a commissioning agreement. Some sign it after the premiere. Let's dive into one of my own commissioning agreements. This is not legal advice, just suggestions.
1. What the piece is for and how long it is
Right at the top of mine, we see that the agreement was made on a certain day between the orchestra and the composer. That's me.
The next thing we have to see is what this piece is going to be for and how long it's going to be. You'd think this is an obvious thing, but it needs to be spelled out in the agreement.
In this case, it's an original musical work for symphony orchestra that's approximately 15 minutes long. Right there, we know what our assignment is as a composer. There's no ifs, ands or buts about whether this is half an hour, 5 minutes or 1 hour. Is this a ballet? Is this a trio? Is this a solo piece for kazoo and electronics? No.
Usually, approximately 15 minutes means somewhere between 12 and 17 or 18 minutes. It doesn't mean 25 minutes.
My agreement also says that the full orchestration is set forth in Exhibit A. That's an extra page at the end of the document that gives you the full list of instrumentation you can go with.
2. When your piece is going to be performed
The next thing we need to know, at least approximately, is when this thing is going to be played.
I think it's okay if it tells you a season, like spring, versus a calendar date. But in my experience, it's a lot better to know exactly when the performances are going to happen.
That way you can plan in advance on being there, and you can figure out when you need to have your piece done.
3. Scores, parts and copying
Hard copies of your score
As far as scores go, they're usually going to want 2 or 3 hard copies that are spiral bound on the left-hand side. That way they can keep the score in their archives, or if there's a conductor or assistant conductor, they can also have a copy.
It's just better that they actually have a hard, tangible score lying around. Maybe they'll play your piece again in a future season. If it's there in their hands, they're going to remember the piece a little bit more than if you just sent it to them electronically.
Digitized parts
With parts for an orchestra or an ensemble, there's going to be 1 of 2 methods. The first one is digitized copies, in other words, PDFs.
If the organization requests PDFs, I like to have a watermark on the bottom of each PDF page. It says that this piece is licensed for use by this specific organization for this specific date.
That way I know that they have that piece for that duration of time, and they can't easily lend it out to other organizations. Otherwise I could find out later on that these other organizations are playing the work without my permission.
I used to not really believe in digitized PDFs, but it's getting harder and harder to not send them. It's easier on the composer side as well as the organization side, so oftentimes I'm okay with digital parts.
Hard copy parts
The second thing you can do is send hard copy parts, usually in an 8 and a half by 11 or 9 by 12 format if you're dealing with orchestra. There are 2 ways to do it.
The first way is that each player in the orchestra, no matter what they play, gets their own part. Even if there are 10 first violins and only 5 stands, all 10 violin players get their own violin 1 part.
The second way has to do with the string players. You give 1 hard copy part per stand. With 10 violins in the first violin section and 2 players per stand, you only have to give 5 parts.
That's a lot easier for the composer, because you just have to give half of what you normally would. And in reality, most string players are not going to practice their part away from the rehearsal. So oftentimes I'd be asked to just give 1 hard copy per stand in the string section.
Who is going to pay for the copying?
The last part of this provision is copying. Is it going to be you as the composer, or is it going to be the organization?
Oftentimes, the fee that you're given is going to cover everything. For me this is a bit better, because then I can control exactly where the money goes. If I'm stuck on time, I can pay someone to do the engraving.
But if someone gave me an engraving fee, and then I end up doing the engraving myself, that's money that could have been spent on the commission itself. So I prefer to keep the fees all in 1 package deal, kind of like how film composers do.
Money that could have been spent on the commission itself
I can control exactly where the money goes
4. How they're going to pay for your piece
Usually, they're going to pay the first half as a lump sum up front, right when you sign the contract. You should be able to receive that first half check within, let's say, 30 days of you both signing.
Then you'd get the second half about, let's say, 30 days after you complete the piece, in other words, deliver the piece.
- Signyou and the organization
- First halfwithin 30 days of you both signing
- Deliveryou complete the piece
- Second halfabout 30 days after
Depending on who you are, you might love or hate this. Most people, I think, love it, because the money is spaced apart and you can use it while you're working on the piece.
For other people, there's this intrinsic pressure when you receive that first half that you have to write the piece. If things go astray, it's difficult to give that money back, especially if you spent it.
The way I am, I want to have that first half so that it could be working for me, whether I need to pay rent or buy food or even invest that money while I'm working on the piece. So I think this fee structure makes sense.

5. Travel and accommodation
A provision that I feel like gets overlooked is what the composer does during the week of the performance. Mainly, what does the composer do in terms of travel and accommodation?
Do you have to pay for your plane ticket, train ticket or Uber ride, and then they'd reimburse you at a certain time later, after the commission? Or are they going to provide all of that for you?
The same goes for accommodation. It could be a hotel, or perhaps they're going to have you stay with a board member or another host.
These things need to be spelled out in the agreement, even if you live in the place where your piece is going to be performed. You never know where you're going to be. You could have another performance the week before, or perhaps you're visiting family the week before or the week after.
6. Who actually owns the copyright
The next provision is probably the most important in the entire agreement, and you need to read it extremely carefully. That is rights. What rights do you and the organization have?
If the organization tells you that this is a work-for-hire commission, or that they own the piece outright, take that contract and just rip it up to shreds in front of them, or just don't answer the email at all.
No, I'm just kidding. Of course answer, but tell them that this is your piece, you wrote the piece, and the piece is not a work-for-hire piece. This is not a film. This is not a project where there are several creative voices contributing to one thing.
This is a project where you're writing a piece and that particular organization is playing it for the first time.
You're going to want to have your piece performed by other organizations and other ensembles, and that first organization is going to want that piece to have a life too.
So make sure that the rights part of your agreement says that you are the sole copyright holder of the piece, both writer and publisher rights. If they tell you that's not okay, just turn 180 degrees and run the other way. This is just not something that's supposed to be in these agreements, and these organizations know that.
Your royalties after the premiere
There's a part B to this. As the copyright holder of your commissioned piece, you're also entitled to performance royalties, through either ASCAP or BMI, after the piece is premiered.
Let's say you have an orchestral performance, and it's going to be played 3 times in 1 weekend. If you're the copyright holder, both writer and publisher, you're going to get 100% of the royalties that come from these 3 performances.
7. Exclusivity rights
The second part of these rights that you need to know about is what we call exclusivity rights. In other words, how long does this ensemble have to play the piece without anyone else performing it?
An ensemble might want exclusivity for 1 whole year from the date of the premiere. If they premiere the piece on, let's say, December 1st, the next ensemble can perform it starting on December 2nd a year later.
Sometimes they even want 2-year exclusivity, sometimes 3-year exclusivity. Sometimes they don't even say anything about exclusivity, in which case you just completely pretend like it's not even there.
Let's say your piece is getting played by a string quartet. If the piece is successful and some other string quartet wants to perform it, you can have them perform it a month later, 2 months later, or whenever during that year, instead of waiting till after an exclusivity period. And that's better for you, obviously, as the composer.
A negotiating tool
This can also be a negotiating tool if you think the commission fee is too low. If they want the piece for 3 years, just say no, you can only have the piece for 1 year, and see what they say. Maybe you meet somewhere in the middle and say 2 years.
- 13 yearsThey say they want the piece for 3 years.
- ?Is the commission fee too low?You want as many things as possible to be in your favor.
- 21 yearJust say no, and see what they say.
- 32 yearsMaybe you meet somewhere in the middle.
Maybe when you're reading this agreement, you think, "Oh, I don't think anyone's going to play the piece within a year." You never know what's going to happen a year down the line, 6 months down the line, 2 months down the line. You want as many things as possible to be in your favor, especially if you cannot get the fee up.
8. Termination and cancellation
The last part of the agreement has to do with termination and cancellation. Mine says that if the composer fails to adhere to the schedule for delivery of score and parts, the orchestra and composer agree to "seek a mutually agreeable rescheduling of the world premiere."
I'd make sure that this specific clause is in the agreement. Maybe you're very busy, and you just don't have time to finish the piece. It would be really terrible if you got almost to the end of when the piece is supposed to be delivered, and you just can't deliver it.
This provision allows you to actually communicate with the organization and see if there can be a mutually agreeable time to have the piece premiered.
If such rescheduling can't be agreed upon by both parties, or the composer fails to adhere to the non-scheduling terms, the orchestra has the right to terminate the agreement with prompt written notice. Then you have to return the money paid to you for the commission, and you're not liable beyond that.
- 1You can't deliver on scheduleMaybe you're very busy, and you just don't have time to finish.
- ?Is there a mutually agreeable time?Orchestra and composer seek a rescheduling of the world premiere.
- 2If not, written noticeThe orchestra has the right to terminate.
- 3You return the moneyAnd you're not liable beyond that.
It should be equal
I think this clause is a little bit skewed towards the orchestra or the organization. There should also be a clause that says if they cannot fulfill their end of the bargain, they need to find a mutually agreed upon time for the piece to be premiered. And if they cannot, the composer should retain the money.
A little bit skewed towards the orchestra
It should be equal
If the organization, for some reason, goes belly up, it shouldn't be your responsibility to give them back your first half of the payment when you did nothing wrong. If the fee is very low, this clause should be in there as well.
9. If they don't give you an agreement
If an organization doesn't provide you a commissioning agreement, don't be afraid to write your own, and model it after some of the things in this post. It's a way for you to go back and forth with your commissioning ensemble.
What to do next
If you'd like more musicians wanting to commission you in the first place, start with my free commissioning guide.
